top of page
  • Writer's pictureLCG Brands Consulting

Dealing with Incompetence and Blame-Shifting in Small Organizations

June 20, 2023

In a small organization, where all team member's contributions are integral to the company's success, encountering an incompetent employee who habitually shifts blame onto others for their lack of work can be a perplexing and uncomfortable situation. However, it is crucial to address this issue promptly and effectively to maintain a healthy work environment and preserve the organization's productivity and morale.

Assessing the Situation is the first step in handling such a predicament. Rather than making hasty judgments or knee-jerk reactions, it's essential to approach the situation objectively. Examining the employee's performance history and records can provide insights into the validity of their claims. Gathering input from colleagues and supervisors can offer a comprehensive perspective.

Once you have a clearer picture, Open Communication becomes pivotal. Initiate a conversation with the underperforming employee but do so in a non-confrontational manner. Express your concerns about their actions and emphasize the impact on the team and the organization as a whole. Encourage them to share their viewpoint and reasons for their behavior.

Providing Constructive Feedback is a critical component of addressing the issue. Give the employee specific feedback on their performance, avoiding blame or accusations. Instead, use concrete examples to illustrate areas that require improvement and suggest actionable steps to enhance their contributions.

To establish clarity and set expectations, Define Clear Responsibilities. Clearly outline the employee's role and responsibilities, ensuring they have a thorough understanding of their job description and the standards they are expected to meet. This proactive measure can help mitigate misunderstandings and excuses.

In cases where the employee lacks necessary skills or resources, it's vital to Offer Support and Resources. Provide training, mentorship, or additional resources to help them enhance their abilities. Demonstrating a commitment to their success can be a motivating factor.

Documenting Everything is crucial throughout this process. Maintain meticulous records of all conversations, feedback, and performance evaluations. Document instances of blame-shifting or failure to fulfill responsibilities. These records can prove invaluable if further actions, such as formal performance improvement plans or disciplinary measures, become necessary.

If the issue persists despite your best efforts, it may be prudent to Involve Higher Management or the HR department. Share the documented evidence and seek guidance on the next steps, which could include more formalized performance improvement plans or disciplinary actions.

To create a more harmonious work environment and reduce the likelihood of such issues recurring, consider implementing Team Building and Conflict Resolution strategies. Address underlying tensions and foster a supportive atmosphere.

Lastly, it's essential to promote a culture of Accountability within the organization. Make it clear that every team member is responsible for their own work, and that blaming others is not acceptable behavior. Lead by example in demonstrating accountability.

Managing an incompetent employee who consistently shifts blame onto others in a small organization requires a delicate balance of patience, communication, and dedication to finding a solution that benefits both the individual and the organization as a whole. By following these steps, you can navigate this challenging situation while preserving a positive work environment and the overall success of the organization.


3 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page